Steve Souder Irishman Award is voted on by teammates and is awarded to the player that epitomizes what Catholic baseball is about – faith, attitude, effort and team.
| Year | Recipient |
| 2022 | Adam Osborn |
| 2021 | Emery Wright |
| 2020 | No award due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 | Connor Witsoe |
| 2018 | Noah Bond |
| 2017 | Macklin Stephenson |
| 2016 | Logan Creech |